Cover of Stone Soup

ROSERAM / LET’S OPEN A BOOK!

Stone Soup

Let’s peek inside Stone Soup! Here’s what makes this story special, a question to get you wondering and a fun idea to try after reading.

Explore this Stone Soup review

A LITTLE PEEK INSIDE

Stone Soup: Meet your next adventure!

A pot, some stones and a curious village: what could possibly be cooking? This warm story shows a meal growing as people join in. The pictures give you lots to explore while a small invitation turns into something everyone can share.

WONDER OUT LOUD

Stone Soup: What do you think?

What could you bring to a meal made together?

YOUR TURN TO PLAY

Stone Soup: Try a little book magic.

Draw a pretend soup with an ingredient chosen by each friend.

ROSERAM’S FULL READING ADVENTURE

Stone Soup: Begin with the particular pot in Jon J Muth’s story

Stone Soup is the title of more than one illustrated retelling. This review is about the version adapted and illustrated by Jon J Muth. Three monks come to a village whose residents are reluctant to offer them company or provisions. The visitors eventually put together a meal with ingredients the people decide to bring. A child can follow the activity one contribution at a time. The story's opening gives the residents reasons to be wary, and the large communal meal gives them a reason to spend time in one another's company. Muth lets a few unremarkable objects make the difference between those two arrangements easy to see.

A family reading it can begin by looking at what the travelers actually have when they arrive. Ask which part of the meal already seems possible and which part is missing. That gives the reader a question they can carry across several pages. Some children will enjoy guessing what ingredient will come next. Others may wonder why a person who has been unwilling to offer anything would decide to participate. The two interests belong together in this version. The practical work of making a meal gives the characters something to do while they change what they expect from one another.

Stone Soup: The stone gives the travelers something to do in public

A pot and a stone make an unusual proposal a person can watch. The neighbors can come near enough to see what is happening without promising very much at first. This is one of the strengths of the familiar tale, and Muth's pictures give it a clear place to happen. The person who chooses to look has an object to look at before being asked to decide whether the visitors deserve their confidence. An adult can ask whether the stone itself has done anything to make the soup taste good. The child may see that its most important work has been to make several people curious about the same thing.

Draw a pretend square with a large empty space in the middle. Put something there that would give a few imaginary neighbors a reason to stop. It might be a bowl, a large piece of paper or an object someone has been trying to identify. Give each person a choice about whether to come closer. This is a useful way to think about how a common project begins. There can be something interesting to see before there is a reason to join in. The result may become a meal in the drawing or a completely different kind of gathering. Let the child decide what makes the invitation work.

Stone Soup: One ingredient changes what the next person can imagine

The story can make the finished meal feel more valuable by letting the reader see what it did not have when it began. A small contribution can change the smell, color or size of what is in the pot. That in turn changes what another person thinks might happen if they add something. The process makes the repeated pattern useful. It is not just a sequence of people bringing things because the story says they do. There is a visible difference between arriving at an empty pot and arriving at a pot that has already made someone else's gift part of a promising meal. A reader can feel a change in the decision as the afternoon proceeds.

Use paper ingredients for a collaborative drawing. Each participant adds one object and says what it makes possible. Somebody who does not want to add food can supply a table, a spoon or a comfortable place for a guest to sit. Give everyone the option of passing. The activity makes room for more than one kind of help and avoids asking a child to bring real food. If a family later wants to cook, use a regular recipe with adult supervision and attention to allergies. The point of the reading activity is what happens when people can see their small choices become part of something they could not make alone.

Stone Soup: The story leaves a question about persuasion

The travelers know more about the planned meal than the people first watching it. They invite those people to act on a story about what might be in the pot. It is possible to enjoy the ingenuity and ask whether the invitation would work if it were described more plainly. The question matters because someone who is reluctant may have a good reason to be careful. Muth's ending shows a benefit the villagers are able to recognize. An older reader can consider what gives the visitors a right to encourage a change and how much of the result depends on the residents making their own choices after they see the activity getting underway.

Try writing two invitations to an invented neighborhood project. One can announce exactly what people would need to bring. The other can invite them to come and see a small thing that has already begun. Ask which invitation feels more trustworthy, which is more interesting and what each could tell the person who is deciding whether to join. A child may write a version that combines the two. This is a good way to take the story's ingenuity seriously without assuming that every clever strategy is fair in every situation. The details of what the guests know and what they get to decide are small enough for a reader to make visible on a single page.

Stone Soup: The watercolor scenes give the village room to change

Muth can make a place look spacious even when there are several people in it. Look at the distance between the travelers and the people who have yet to come near. Then look at what changes when the pot begins to draw a crowd. The figures' positions tell a reader something about interest and willingness before a line of text has to announce it. The palette and the areas left open help the pace feel quiet enough for a family to look for those signs. This is a different sort of pleasure from a read-aloud built chiefly around noise or a series of loud surprises. A listener can see how the people have moved closer while the words describe what is being added to the meal.

Kirkus Reviews praises the grace of the figures and the backgrounds while finding the text's lesson rather stiff. That is a useful difference to think about while reading. Ask what the pictures have already shown before the final explanation is spoken. A child may identify one detail that makes the outcome clear without any summary of what they ought to learn. The pictures deserve time of their own, especially if the moral sounds familiar to an adult. A young reader who is looking carefully can find something quite particular about how a person decides to come out of a house or share a place at a table.

Stone Soup: Choose the cultural context with care

Muth relocates a widely retold tale to a Chinese setting and gives his adaptation three monks and an explicit question about happiness. It is useful to identify those features as choices of this version. The book can be read beside another telling without assuming that every version came from the setting that appears in its pictures. It should also be possible to discuss the people in the village as characters whose experiences the illustrator has selected, without turning them into an explanation of what people in China are like. A family interested in the setting can look at the book's afterword and then use other sources to follow any historical or cultural questions it raises.

If you are comparing two stories in a classroom, give each one its own record of the person who adapted it and the artist who made the pictures. Note what the people in each version bring to the gathering and what they appear to learn. Ask which details are shared and which belong to a particular telling. The comparison gives students a way to be specific about change. It is much more useful than asking which one is the real story without first knowing what kind of evidence would settle that question. The activity can also lead a child to choose the next version by how they would like the characters to sound.

Stone Soup: Spoilers for the meal and the answer it offers

The story ends with people eating together and describing what the visit has meant to them. The satisfaction comes from seeing the previous reluctance become something the participants can talk about after the work is done. A reader may find the direct explanation welcome. Another may feel that the gathering itself had already made the point. The best discussion leaves room for both responses. Ask what will still be there when the travelers leave. The pot will no longer contain the same meal. The neighbors may now have a memory of an activity they can imagine doing again. That is a more interesting result to picture than a village whose problems are all supposed to disappear at the end of a feast.

Draw the place the next morning. Give one resident a small reason to speak to somebody they did not know well before. They can ask a question, bring a leftover ingredient or offer a different place to meet. There is no need to invent a large new project. The activity works if the reader can name one useful change in what a person thinks is possible. A child may choose someone who watched without joining and give that person time to make a decision now. The book leaves plenty of room for such a sequel because the most important thing the meal has produced may be an occasion for another conversation.

Stone Soup: Choose a copy by the adapter and the illustrator

Look for Jon J Muth on the cover and in the listing. Marcia Brown's Stone Soup and other books with the same title are different retellings. Check the characters and pictures in a sample if a seller's title is abbreviated. Scholastic lists several formats, including books with accompanying audio. Look carefully at the selected format and ISBN before comparing totals. A larger picture book gives the watercolor changes room to be seen by several readers. A library copy can be useful for comparing Muth and Brown without having to choose which one should be the permanent copy at home. Match the format and condition before judging the full price including delivery.

Click, Clack, Moo offers another way for a group to make its needs visible, with a far more comic disagreement and a different kind of resolution. Blueberries for Sal gives the pleasure of finding food a more intimate scale. The Story of Ferdinand offers an illustrated story that is willing to wait for a small change in the way people behave. Muth's Stone Soup works best when the reader wants to see people spend time on a practical thing together. Roseram's original children's collection offers more illustrated stories to browse when the family wants another way of bringing different characters into the same room.

Stone Soup: Our verdict: look closely at what people actually contribute

Muth's version is a thoughtful choice when you want the familiar story to feel slow enough for a gathering to develop. The setting and the watercolor art make it a good candidate for comparing with another version, and the direct statement of the lesson may suit some readers more than others. Give the child time to see the first and last pictures of the meal-making and ask which change feels most significant. The answer might be an ingredient or the arrival of a particular person. Both are evidence that the reader has been able to follow more than the fact that the soup is finally ready.

For a short final activity, make a list of the jobs that would let several fictional people share a meal. Include something a visitor could do and something a person at home could choose to offer. Let the child give one character a reason to wait before deciding. The list can become a tiny story if it ends with one detail that the people could only have made together. This is the quiet pleasure of Muth's retelling. A finished meal lets the reader see an afternoon's worth of choices in one place, and the pictures give them room to notice what went into making it possible.

OTHER VOICES · ATTRIBUTED EXCERPTS

Stone Soup: A peek at published feedback.

These selected published excerpts come from the named sources. They are not reviews submitted to Roseram or a complete picture of every reader’s opinion.

Professional editorial review excerptKirkus Reviews editorial staff · Kirkus Reviews
graceful, traditionally dressed figures with expressive, delicately drawn faces

The review distinguishes its appreciation of the art from its reservations about the text.

Read the original source ↗

MORE BOOKS TO EXPLORE

Stone Soup: Snuggle up with another story.

Looking for a picture-book friend? These stories have lovely little worlds to explore together.

For grown-ups: book editions and prices

PRICE & EDITION COMPARISON

Stone Soup: Compare like with like.

Retail prices change by country, seller and date. A reliable comparison matches the ISBN, binding, language, publication date and condition, then includes shipping and tax. Check a new copy against another new copy, a used copy against the same edition in similar condition, and a library listing separately. We include publisher-listed reference prices when available; they are not a live survey of every retailer and are not presented as the lowest price.

1 Match ISBN and format2 Check condition and seller3 Include delivery and tax
Check bibliographic records for this title ↗

Stone Soup: Explore the book’s background

The reference explains the traditional folktale behind Jon J. Muth’s retelling; it is not an article devoted to his edition.

For grown-ups: about our reviews and sources

SCOPE & SOURCES

Stone Soup: A clear basis for this review.

This is Roseram’s original editorial commentary on the work’s narrative, form and reader experience. It is independent of the book’s publisher and is not a customer rating, sponsored endorsement, or report of a hands-on test of a particular edition. Illustrations, translations, introductions and pagination can differ between editions.

For edition-specific publication details, compare the title and author in the public library catalog. No reader ratings or price quotes are presented unless a linked source identifies the exact edition.

Look up bibliographic records for this title