Cover of Miss Nelson Is Missing!

ROSERAM / LET’S OPEN A BOOK!

Miss Nelson Is Missing!

Let’s peek inside Miss Nelson Is Missing!! Here’s what makes this story special, a question to get you wondering and a fun idea to try after reading.

Explore this Miss Nelson Is Missing! review

A LITTLE PEEK INSIDE

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Meet your next adventure!

Miss Nelson's class is about to discover that a new teacher can be a BIG surprise! The pictures leave clues while the children try to work out what happened. This funny school mystery is extra enjoyable when you pause and make a guess.

WONDER OUT LOUD

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: What do you think?

Which picture gives you a clue about the mystery?

YOUR TURN TO PLAY

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Try a little book magic.

Make a little detective notebook with three clues from the story.

ROSERAM’S FULL READING ADVENTURE

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: The room is already telling a story

Harry Allard and James Marshall introduce Room 207 as a place where each small action creates an excuse for the next. A child can look from one desk to another and find a whole series of things Miss Nelson has to attend to at once. The commotion is funny because it is specific. Marshall lets a piece of paper and a small change in someone's posture show how much is happening in the time it takes the teacher to ask for attention. Young readers may spot an object or an expression before the adult does. That gives them a reason to look closely at a page that might otherwise seem to say only that the class is noisy.

The book starts well as a shared reading if you let the child describe the room in two or three details. Ask which thing they would notice first if they were trying to hear a story there. A reader might be interested in a person who cannot get comfortable, or the route an object has taken across the room. Give those observations room before asking how Miss Nelson feels. It is easier to understand the scale of the trouble after seeing what she has to do to hold one conversation. The pictures turn the class into a place you can imagine visiting for a few very busy minutes.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Miss Nelson’s warmth makes the disappearance matter

Miss Nelson has already offered the children something they can enjoy together. Her interest in sharing a story gives the room a possible purpose that keeps getting interrupted. That matters when she is absent. The children notice what had been available to them before they had any reason to value it. Allard makes the lost pleasure quite concrete. A reader can recognize the difference between being allowed to take part in an enjoyable activity and being able to hear the person who is trying to lead it. That connection gives the book something to say about an ordinary group even if everyone in the room knows the story's secret.

A useful pause comes after the class first encounters a different routine. Ask what the children would most like to get back. Someone may choose the stories, while someone else may say they miss a voice or the chance to ask a question without being afraid. Then ask which part of that experience the class could help make possible. It can be enough for a group of fictional children to try one practical change. The discussion should leave room for children who know what it is like to be interrupted and children who sometimes have a hard time being still. Both can want a chance to enjoy a good story.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Miss Viola Swamp changes the temperature of the classroom

The substitute's appearance and manner give the story a quick change of rhythm. The children are told what to do, the expectations are different and there is much less room to see how far the conversation can wander. Marshall makes Swamp a strong shape on the page. That is useful when reading to a group that needs to see the difference from the other side of a room. The picture gets a reaction before the children in it have worked out what is going to happen. Allard can spend the remaining time on how the class responds to having a day they can no longer organize around their usual distractions.

A gentle performance can make the substitute's voice measured instead of frighteningly loud. A child may enjoy hearing a pause after an instruction and finding how the picture supplies the effect. Some listeners are uneasy about teachers who seem severe or about a trusted adult being missing. Give them the option of hearing where the story is headed before spending time on that part. This is a comedy built from a deliberately large change in the adults' behavior. Its effects can be entertaining and still prompt a reader to ask what it would feel like to be in the room. Let those questions belong in the reading.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: The children become wonderfully unreliable detectives

Their ideas about what happened to Miss Nelson make the disappearance larger than the actual evidence would warrant. This is one of the story's best opportunities to hear the children use their unruliness for something interesting. They can generate possibilities very quickly, and a possibility can be exciting even when it leaves all the important questions unanswered. The detective the children consult does not immediately solve things for them. The book lets their speculation have a little life of its own. A reader can be amused by a wild theory and at the same time look for the ordinary explanation the people in the story have overlooked.

Make two columns on a sheet of paper, one for something a character actually saw and one for an idea about what might have happened. Choose one clue from a picture and place it in the first column. Then invent a deliberately spectacular theory and see how much of it the clue supports. This keeps the game funny and makes the difference between observation and inference easy to use. A younger reader can do the same thing with two drawings. One might show the door the class can see, and the other might show somewhere nobody in the book has actually visited. Let the child move a guess when they discover new information.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Marshall saves small details for the reader who looks twice

The art can give a small object enough visibility to be found and enough company to be passed over. An older listener may know that a mystery usually expects them to look for clues and still enjoy having to choose what deserves their attention. A younger listener may concentrate on a face that has changed between the teacher's question and the children's reply. Both readers are using what the drawings make available. The range of image sizes also affects the reading. A large scene can show how the class acts as a group, while a smaller portrait gives an individual reaction somewhere to happen.

Kirkus Reviews described the plot as predictable and found enjoyment in the telling and the broadly comic illustrations. That is a fair account of why the book is still worth looking at if the solution seems obvious. A read-aloud can ask the child what they noticed before they heard the words. On a second pass, find one piece of a busy drawing that has nothing to do with solving the mystery. It may be the detail that gives the room the most character. These small visual pleasures do much of the work in a book whose final explanation a reader may have guessed long before the final picture.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Spoilers for the identity of the substitute

Miss Nelson and Miss Viola Swamp are the same person in the story's solution. The last visual clues give the reader a chance to connect the two appearances without a long explanation to the class. That choice makes the ending funnier because a listener can know something the children still have not settled. It also means the reader can revisit earlier encounters to see how much the two performances seemed to share. A child who is new to a mystery with a visual reveal may find it helpful to describe the last object they saw before saying who it belongs to. That makes the act of reaching a conclusion part of the pleasure.

There is an interesting question about which parts of the change come from the costume and which parts come from the person choosing how to act. Draw a character wearing two different hats, then write one line they might say while wearing each. Try exchanging the lines and see if the child can still recognize the intended roles. The game can be completely friendly. It is about how a storyteller can guide a reader's first impression and give the same reader a chance to revise it later. Miss Nelson's two appearances make that problem understandable to a child who may never have read a longer mystery.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: A funny picture book can leave a real classroom question

The story uses deception and exaggerated severity to produce a quick change. A reader can enjoy the joke and ask how a class could make its days better in ways that would work beyond the end of the book. Clear expectations, a routine that helps children know when to listen, and a chance for the teacher to understand what is difficult are all possibilities a group can imagine. The book does not have to be read as a guide to disciplining children. It is more interesting as a story that makes a shift in power and behavior very easy to see. A family or classroom can think about the effect without reenacting the treatment.

It is also worth noticing how the disguise uses visual ideas about beauty, age and unpleasantness to signal who is meant to be frightening. Ask what really tells the reader how Swamp treats the class. The answer will likely include what she says, how she makes people feel and what she asks them to do. You can draw a different costume for a character who will change the classroom's routine. Make the design surprising without making someone's real physical features a reason to suspect them. It is an accessible way to discuss what a picture can imply and what the reader can look for before accepting the implication.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Give a reading group a job it can actually share

For a group of younger listeners, choose one moment when everyone can point quietly to a clue. Then let a willing reader describe where the clue sits. The choice gives a child who is not ready to speak a way to take part and gives the group a reason to wait a little longer before turning the page. You can make a second reading a search for changes in the room rather than a race to announce the solution. Ask who has a good view of what is happening and who seems to have missed an important event. A reader can contribute even when the main secret has already been worked out.

For older children, try writing a note from an invented substitute who has walked into a different busy room. Give the substitute one thing they want to learn about the class and one change they want to try. Then give a student a note to write back. The replies can be comic and still tell us something about the room. This is a good project for a child who likes the school setting but wants a role that belongs to someone other than the detective. It also keeps the book's classroom concerns attached to specific choices about how people might talk to each other.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Choose the right Miss Nelson edition and neighboring read

Look for Harry Allard and James Marshall and match the full title Miss Nelson Is Missing! Other books about the character and compilations of multiple stories can appear beside the original in a shop or library search. Check the table of contents if you are buying a collection. A larger illustrated copy can make the classroom details easier for a group to see, while a small copy may be convenient for one reader. Compare the ISBN, format and condition before comparing the price with shipping included. A library copy is enough to try the performance and find out whether a child prefers to know the answer or work it out from the pictures.

The True Story of the Three Little Pigs suits a reader who wants another reason to question what a speaker says about an event. Caps for Sale makes a good companion when the reader liked predicting a group's response, with a different kind of repetition and no school discipline. Chrysanthemum offers a more personal classroom story about the attention children give a classmate. Miss Nelson Is Missing! is particularly enjoyable when the reader wants to inspect what changed and have a laugh at how many guesses a small problem can invite. Roseram's original children's collection offers additional illustrated stories to browse for the next shared reading.

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Leave the room with one more mystery to invent

Draw two pictures of an ordinary room. In the second, move or replace one thing. Give someone a reason to notice and let another reader decide what the change could mean. Keep the stakes as small as you like. Perhaps a chair was turned so somebody could see a bird outside, or a pile of paper moved because the person sitting there wanted room to draw. The maker can include another clue and let the reader adjust their first theory. The activity draws out the book's affection for explanations that grow from a recognizable detail, even after a group has enjoyed guessing something much larger than the eventual answer.

Miss Nelson Is Missing! is strongest as a playful mystery whose pictures let children know more than some of its characters. The speed of the behavioral change and the caricature of the substitute are fair subjects for a discussion. The quick plotting also makes the story easy to reread in a new mood. You can follow the commotion on one occasion and the teacher's part in it on another. A good ending to a shared reading may be asking which person would notice first if tomorrow's classroom changed in one small way. The child who suggests a funny answer has probably found the part of the story they most want to carry away.

OTHER VOICES · ATTRIBUTED EXCERPTS

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: A peek at published feedback.

These selected published excerpts come from the named sources. They are not reviews submitted to Roseram or a complete picture of every reader’s opinion.

Professional editorial review excerptKirkus Reviews editorial staff · Kirkus Reviews
there’s fun in the telling

The review discusses the predictable mystery and Marshall’s visual comedy. It reveals the solution.

Read the original source ↗

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Sources for this reading guide

MORE BOOKS TO EXPLORE

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Stories with a heart.

Meet some more storybook friends. Their adventures bring kindness, big feelings and lots to wonder about together.

For grown-ups: book editions and prices

PRICE & EDITION COMPARISON

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Compare like with like.

Retail prices change by country, seller and date. A reliable comparison matches the ISBN, binding, language, publication date and condition, then includes shipping and tax. Check a new copy against another new copy, a used copy against the same edition in similar condition, and a library listing separately. We include publisher-listed reference prices when available; they are not a live survey of every retailer and are not presented as the lowest price.

1 Match ISBN and format2 Check condition and seller3 Include delivery and tax
Check bibliographic records for this title ↗

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: Explore the book’s background

Read the encyclopedia entry for more publication history and background.

For grown-ups: about our reviews and sources

SCOPE & SOURCES

Miss Nelson Is Missing!: A clear basis for this review.

This is Roseram’s original editorial commentary on the work’s narrative, form and reader experience. It is independent of the book’s publisher and is not a customer rating, sponsored endorsement, or report of a hands-on test of a particular edition. Illustrations, translations, introductions and pagination can differ between editions.

For edition-specific publication details, compare the title and author in the public library catalog. No reader ratings or price quotes are presented unless a linked source identifies the exact edition.

Look up bibliographic records for this title